Writing Historical Accuracy in 7 Steps for Realistic Stories

You’re right—writing historically accurate stories can feel intimidating. With countless dates, events, and details, it’s easy to worry you’ll miss something important and get called out by sharp-eyed history fans.

But don’t stress! This guide will walk you through clear, straightforward steps to nail historical accuracy without losing your mind…or your readers. By the end, you’ll confidently weave realistic details, believable characters, and convincing dialogue into your historical fiction.

Ready to get started? Let’s dive into step one!

Step 1: Research Historical Facts Carefully

The first rule to nailing historical accuracy is strong, careful research. History can be tricky, details matter, and readers today have access to instant fact-checking tools—so no shortcuts here!

Start by exploring reputable sources like Smithsonian Libraries and Archives or academic databases such as EBSCO where you can access historical documents and primary sources.

Focus on facts relevant to your story, such as cultural norms, locations, technology, and significant events. For instance, if your tale takes place in 19th-century America, keep in mind historical data like the massive immigration wave between 1850 and 1890, when over 3 million people arrived in the U.S.

Take detailed notes and organize them clearly using folders or digital note-taking apps like Notion or Evernote. Include direct quotes or exact dates so you avoid confusion later.

Double-check all essential dates or events with multiple sources instead of relying on just one article—you don’t want to accidentally spread historical myths or inaccuracies!

Step 2: Include Realistic Details from the Time Period

Here’s the thing, authenticity in historical fiction isn’t just about dates and big events. The tiny everyday details often make all the difference and build trust with your readers.

Use accurate descriptions of clothing styles, food, transportation, and household items in the period you’re writing about. For instance, if your story is set during the Industrial Revolution period, you might touch on America’s swift economic growth—the nation’s GDP skyrocketed from about $1.5 billion in 1790 to over $12 billion by 1900.

Talking about clothes? Digging into vintage fashion archives or museum collections online can help you describe realistic wardrobe choices.

Adding authentic, vivid sensory details can immerse readers. Instead of simply saying someone cooked dinner, briefly describe the smell of stew simmering on a wood-burning stove.

If you’re short on ideas, you can check out some historical fiction writing prompts to spark inspiration and practice blending historical detail with storytelling skills.

Step 3: Write Believable Characters for Your Historical Setting

Creating engaging characters who feel authentic in historical settings takes a little finesse. You can’t simply drop modern attitudes or behavior into a setting hundreds of years ago—it just doesn’t ring true.

Your character should hold values, speech patterns, and motivations believable within their historical context. Exploring how rapidly global population changed—from about 1 billion around 1800 to roughly 2.5 billion by 1950—can give you insight into how people of that era viewed the world.

Think carefully about their backstories, family histories, occupations, and belief systems, ensuring they match the values of their historical era; this doesn’t mean you can’t challenge typical roles or beliefs, but the way your characters view these issues needs to feel believable.

Also, consider giving your characters everyday struggles consistent with the period. Someone living in medieval Europe would realistically worry about harvests, disease, or social status, rather than modern anxieties like internet connectivity.

For shaping lifelike characters, try experimenting with fun character writing prompts to flesh out their personalities and make sure they align with your historical details.

Step 4: Choose Language That Fits the Historical Era

The way your characters speak can either make or break the realism of your historical fiction.

To choose period-appropriate language, spend some time reading books, diaries, or newspapers published around the same era you’re writing about.

This helps you catch terms, phrases, and even idioms your characters would naturally use, making dialogue flow smoothly and naturally.

For older periods, like medieval Europe, it’s tempting to fill your pages with “thees” and “thous,” but be cautious—overdoing this can pull your readers out of the story.

A little goes a long way: sprinkle period-specific language gently, just enough to give readers the flavor without exhausting them.

Also, avoid overly modern slang or references—if a character in the 1800s says something “rocks,” readers are going to do a double take.

Need extra tips on crafting convincing dialogue? Check out this guide to formatting dialogue properly and authentically to keep readers engaged.

Step 5: Decide When It’s Acceptable to Adjust Historical Facts for Your Story

Is it okay to tweak historical facts sometimes? It can be, as long as you’re upfront with readers and can justify your choices.

Adjusting minor, non-essential details can sometimes improve your plot—but significant historical events should generally remain accurate.

Think critically about why you’re changing something: does it make your plot clearer, more exciting, or easier to follow?

If your adjustment involves big events—like major wars, reigns, or discoveries—be transparent about this decision either in an author’s note or endnote, so readers understand your intention.

A quick tip: many writers choose to create fictional towns or minor characters to give their story flexibility without altering verified history too drastically.

To avoid confusion, keep detailed notes on the changes you’ve made and why, ensuring consistency across your narrative.

Step 6: Match the Storyline to Historical Events and Settings

Your plot doesn’t have to hinge directly on huge historical events, but it should weave naturally within the historical context you’ve chosen.

If you’re setting a story during the economic boom of the Industrial Revolution, consider how those rapid transformations—like the leap in U.S. GDP from $1.5 billion in 1790 to over $12 billion by 1900—affected everyday lives.

Your characters might face dilemmas specific to their era, like migration, unemployment due to mechanization, or shifting social class structures.

Realistically tying in historical events—like the large-scale immigration wave into the United States between 1850 and 1890—can add depth without overshadowing personal stories.

Matching your plot with notable events and settings helps readers connect your fictional characters with genuine struggles, effectively bringing history to life.

To keep ideas flowing, check out these compelling historical fiction writing prompts to blend your story effortlessly with genuine historical backgrounds.

Step 7: Review and Edit Your Writing for Historical Mistakes

There’s nothing more frustrating as a reader—or embarrassing as a writer—than stumbling over glaring historical inaccuracies after publishing.

Even if you’ve double-checked facts, details can slip past, especially if you’re absorbed in storytelling.

Your best move is getting feedback from someone familiar with your chosen era—a beta reader knowledgeable about that historical period can point out potential slips.

Also, cross-reference details once more before finalizing your draft—use trusted databases like the Smithsonian Libraries and Archives to verify facts again.

When editing, pay close attention to small yet crucial details like character ages, timelines, clothing materials, technology, and daily practices.

Lastly, trust your instincts—if a passage seems somehow off historically, recheck it sooner rather than later to avoid challenges down the line.

FAQs