Picking a great short story anthology can feel overwhelming—too many options, too little time, and what if you pick a book that just isn’t your thing?
I get it, and that’s why I’ve rounded up an easy-to-follow guide on the best short story collections across different genres, award-winning titles, classics that still feel fresh today, and exciting stories from emerging and diverse voices. Plus, I’ll throw in some quick tips to help you find the collection you’ll actually love reading.
Ready to find your next favorite book? Let’s jump right in.
Key Takeaways
- Short story anthologies offer quick, satisfying reads across genres like mystery, romance, and horror.
- Recent popular collections include Tom Hanks’ Uncommon Type, Kristen Roupenian’s relationship-focused stories, and Nana Kwame Adjei-Brenyah’s gripping Friday Black.
- Great genre-specific picks include The Best American Mystery Stories for mystery fans, Stephen King’s Night Shift for horror lovers, and Meet Cute for romance enthusiasts.
- Check out award-winning anthologies like The Secret Lives of Church Ladies, Tenth of December, and Her Body and Other Parties for exceptional storytelling.
- Explore fresh perspectives through diverse anthologies such as Black Enough, A People’s Future of the United States, and Disability Visibility.
- Classic anthologies worth reading include Anton Chekhov’s stories, Joyce’s Dubliners, and Shirley Jackson’s The Lottery and Other Stories.
Best Short Story Anthologies to Read Now
If you’re thinking about exploring short stories but aren’t sure where to start, consider picking up anthologies that have recently captured the spotlight and impressed readers everywhere. With short story collections experiencing a surprising sales boost—almost 50% growth in 2017—it’s clear that these literary gems are making a big comeback.
A couple standouts you definitely shouldn’t miss include Uncommon Type: Some Stories by Tom Hanks, which quickly became a bestseller thanks to his relatable characters and genuine humor, and Kristen Roupenian’s electrifying stories that tackled modern relationships. These two collections alone helped boost short story sales, representing around 22% of the anthology market share the same year.
Another great pick right now is Friday Black by Nana Kwame Adjei-Brenyah. His powerful, thought-provoking narratives have received attention from major literary circles, and readers can’t seem to put it down. So, if you’re looking for an exciting entry-point, give one of these popular yet accessible anthologies a shot.
Popular Short Story Anthologies by Genre
Sometimes, you’re in the mood for a particular type of short story—and luckily, there are anthologies tailored for just about every genre imaginable. This is helpful because it means you won’t have to skip around or guess whether the next story is something you’ll enjoy.
For mystery buffs, a great anthology to explore is The Best American Mystery Stories, edited annually by different acclaimed mystery authors like Louise Penny and Lee Child. It gives you gripping whodunnits that you can breeze through in one sitting.
If you’re a fan of exploring darker themes, Stephen King’s classic anthology Night Shift brings together some truly haunting stories that’ll stick with you long past bedtime. You might even be inspired enough to start writing your own chilling tales—be sure to check out these intriguing horror story plot ideas for a little extra inspiration.
Prefer romance? Then try the anthology Meet Cute: Some People Are Destined to Meet, featuring adorable, feel-good stories by authors like Nicola Yoon and Katharine McGee. It’s perfect when you need a quick pick-me-up that leaves you smiling.
Recent Award-Winning Anthologies to Check Out
Award-winning collections are a reliable way to discover exceptional short stories from diverse and talented voices. These anthologies not only showcase top-tier storytelling but also represent the literary world’s best current offerings.
One top choice worth exploring is The Secret Lives of Church Ladies by Deesha Philyaw, winner of the 2021 PEN/Faulkner Award. Her relatable stories focus on the complexities within families and relationships, with razor-sharp wit and beautiful writing.
Another celebrated anthology is George Saunders’ Tenth of December, a finalist for the National Book Award and lauded for profound character explorations combined with a humor that genuinely resonates. These stories can spark all kinds of ideas—perfect if you’re considering becoming a beta reader or dipping your toes into fiction writing yourself.
Finally, consider checking out Carmen Maria Machado’s groundbreaking collection, Her Body and Other Parties, a National Book Award finalist that innovatively blends fantasy, horror, and realism, leaving readers contemplating each story long after reading.
Anthologies Featuring New and Diverse Authors
If you’re up for discovering different cultures and fresh voices, you should definitely pick anthologies highlighting new and diverse authors making their mark on the literary scene.
A great example is Black Enough: Stories of Being Young & Black in America by Ibi Zoboi—this anthology gathers powerful and relatable voices exploring experiences of young Black Americans today.
You might also enjoy A People’s Future of the United States edited by Victor LaValle and John Joseph Adams—it’s packed with speculative tales by diverse authors imagining America’s future.
Another cool suggestion is Disability Visibility: First-Person Stories from the Twenty-First Century, edited by Alice Wong, which shares personal essays and short stories from disabled writers, offering insights you likely haven’t considered.
Classic Short Story Anthologies That Stand the Test of Time
Looking for guaranteed good reads? Classics are classics for a reason—they never disappoint.
An absolute must-read is The Stories of Anton Chekhov, because Chekhov basically shaped the modern short story—plus, he’s surprisingly funny and sharp, even today.
Another timeless choice is Dubliners by James Joyce; trust me, these stories perfectly capture the richness of everyday life and struggles in early 20th-century Dublin, and they’ll stay with you long after you finish reading.
Don’t skip Shirley Jackson’s collection, The Lottery and Other Stories, iconic for its eerie title story that challenged readers’ expectations back when it was published and still does today—perfect for anyone fascinated with learning how to write suspenseful narratives, and if that’s your thing, you might want to explore these intriguing dystopian plot generator ideas to fuel your creativity.
Tips on Choosing the Best Short Story Anthology for You
Wondering how you can pick the perfect anthology that you’ll actually enjoy?
First things first, think about what themes you naturally gravitate toward in books or movies—do you prefer romance, mystery, sci-fi, or realistic stories?
Always look for anthologies edited or endorsed by an author you already love; chances are, their picks will match your taste.
Check out a few samples or reviews online; this quick step can reveal if the author’s style is your cup of tea before you commit to a whole book.
If you’re serious about writing and thinking ahead about publishing, a short story anthology is a great way to understand different story structures and voices. You might even find inspiration and learn actionable tips from experienced writers—such as how to get your book published without an agent.
Lastly, don’t shy away from trying something totally new once in a while—it can help you discover surprising favorites you’d never imagined enjoying.
FAQs
Consider factors like your preferred genre, favorite authors, themes that resonate, or authors’ cultural backgrounds. Reviews, reader recommendations, and excerpts can also help in finding anthologies that match your reading preferences and personal interests.
Popular anthology genres include literary fiction, science fiction, fantasy, horror, mystery, romance, and historical fiction. Each offers unique storytelling styles, making it easier for readers to find appealing collections that suit their personal genre interests.
Look into specialized publishers, literary journals, and independent bookstores that highlight diverse voices. Anthologies edited by known advocates for diversity or those released by independent presses regularly feature emerging and underrepresented authors from varied backgrounds.
Classic anthologies like “The Best American Short Stories”, “The Norton Anthology of Short Fiction”, and anthologies featuring renowned writers like O. Henry, Edgar Allan Poe, or Anton Chekhov continue to maintain popularity among readers due to timeless storytelling.
